Seminars in Diagnostic Pathology
Volume 24, Issue 2 , Pages 131-147 , May 2007

Tort reform: the pathologists’ perspective

  • Elliott Foucar, MD

      Affiliations

    • Retired from clinical practice, Albuquerque, New Mexico
    • Corresponding Author InformationAddress reprint requests and correspondence: Elliott Foucar, MD, 14029 Wind Mtn Rd NE, Albuquerque, NM 87112-6564.
    • ,
  • Mark R. Wick, MD

      Affiliations

    • Division of Surgical Pathology and Cytopathology, University of Virginia Medical Center, Charlottesville, Virginia.

References 

  1. Jacobson PD, Bloche MG. Improving relations between attorneys and physicians. J Am Med Assoc. 2005;294:2083–2085
  2. Interview (An “awful” tort system, AMA). United Press International. 2006;September 1. Available at: http://upi.com/HealthBusiness. Accessed September 1, 2006.
  3. Mohr JC. American medical malpractice litigation in historical perspective. J Am Med Assoc. 2000;283:1731–1737
  4. Searcy Denney Scarola Barnhart & Shipley (Tort reform threatens civil rights). A quarterly report to clients and attorneys, Vol. 03, No. 1. 2005;Available at: http://www.searcylaw.com. Accessed November 9
  5. Center for Justice and Democracy (CJ&D) (Glossary of “tort reforms.”). 2006;Available at: http://centerjd.org/free/mythbusters-free/MB_glossary.htm. Accessed September 5
  6. Webster’s Seventh New Collegiate Dictionary. Springfield, MA: G&C Merriam Company; 1963;
  7. Guadagnino C. Expertise-enhancing reform of medical malpractice litigation (Physician’s News Digest, December 2003). 2006;Available at: http://www.physiciansnews.com/spotlight/1203.html. Accessed September 15
  8. Dillard SC. Litigation nation. In: The Wall Street Journal. 2006;p. A9;November 25, 26
  9. Memorandum, Wyoming Legislative Service Office (Summary of liability caps imposed in other states and medical liability insurance rates). 2006;Available at: http://legisweb.state.wy.us. July 9, 2004. Accessed August 8
  10. McCullough, Campbell, & Lane LLP (Summary of Medical Malpractice Law (Virginia), June 2, 2003). 2006;Available at: http://www.mcandl.com/virginia.html. Accessed September 15
  11. Studdert DM, Yang YT, Mello MM. Are damage caps regressive? (A study of malpractice jury verdicts in California). Health Aff. 2004;23:54–67
  12. Plested WG. Starting the new year with our priorities set realistically. American Medical News. 2007;30;January 22
  13. Center for Justice and Democracy (Med mal insurer dumping states with severe “tort reforms”: more evidence that caps do not work. News release. September 26, 2003). 2006;Available at: http://centerjd.org. Accessed September 5
  14. Common Dreams Progressive Newswire. Center for Justice and Democracy study refutes American Medical Association Claims of “crisis” in 18 states. News release. 2006;Available at: http://www.commondreams.org/news2003/0424-04.htm. April 24, 2003. Accessed September 5
  15. Smith C, McCoy C. Alternate solutions for rising medical malpractice insurance premiums. American Medical Student Association. September 15, 2006. 2006;Available at: http://www.amsa.org. Accessed September 15
  16. (Californians Allied for Patient Protection), The Coalition to Protect MICRA. About MICRA. 2006;Available at: http://www.micra.org/AboutMICRA.htm. Accessed July 27
  17. Ceniceros R. Malpractice reform heats up; Doctors insurance costs, losses attracting state and federal attention. Business Insurance, January 13, 2003, page 1, cited by Loh C. An overview of medical malpractice and the tort reform debate. April 23, 2003. 2006;Available at: http://case.edu/med/epidbio/mphp439/Malpractice.htm. Accessed September 1
  18. Norbut M. Three crisis states report improvement since tort reform. American Medical News. 2005;Vol 48:1;March 28
  19. Gingrich N, Gill JT. Prodigal state. The Wall Street Journal. 2006;A15;May 4
  20. Sorrel AL. Liability insurance rates mostly hold steady or drop this year. In: American Medical News. 2006;p. 1;December 11
  21. Norbut M. Wisconsin court strikes liability caps. In: American Medical News. Vol 48:2005;p. 1;August 1
  22. McCullough, Campbell, & Lane LLP. Summary of Medical Malpractice Law (New Mexico). February 6, 1998. 2007;Available at: http://www.mcandl.com/newmexico.html#IX. Accessed January 29
  23. National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies (NAMIC Online). Joint and several liability reform states. January 1, 2004. 2006;Available at: http://www.namic.org. Accessed September 7
  24. Worsley B. The many facets of vicarious liability. Schweickert & Company. 2004. 2006;Available at: http://schweickert.com/p-vicarious.htm. Accessed September 29
  25. Sorrel AL. Court upholds doctors’ right to pay only part of jury award. American Medical News. 2006;13;November 6
  26. The Independent Institute. Book review of: Judge and Jury, American Tort Law on Trial, by Eric A Helland and Alexander Tabarrok. 2007;Available at: http://independent.org/publications/books/book_summary.asp?bookID=62. Accessed January 12
  27. Creswell J. So small a town, so many patent suits. The New York Times. 2006;1;Section 3, September 24
  28. Cass RA. Forum-shopper of the year. The Wall Street Journal. 2007;A13;January 12
  29. Norbut M. Physicians in 4 states score tort reform wins. American Medical News. 2005;5;April 18
  30. Sorrel AL. Liability insurance rates steadying amid hopeful signs on tort reform. American Medical News. 2006;Vol 49:1;May 1
  31. Yoon A, Baker T. Offer-of-judgment rules and civil litigation: an empirical study of automobile insurance litigation in the East. No date provided. 2006;Available at: http://www.utexas.edu/law/academics/centers/clbe/assets/YoonAlbert_paper_11_08.pdf. Accessed October 3
  32. Struve CT. Improving the medical malpractice litigation process. Health Aff. 2004;23:33–41
  33. Fraser JJ Committee on Medical Liability. American Academy of Pediatrics: Technical report: alternative dispute resolution in medical malpractice. Pediatrics. 2001;107:602–607
  34. Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. Does mediation work better than trial for settling medical malpractice cases? September 2002. 2007;Available at: http://www.rwjf.org/reports/grr/032057.htm. Accessed January 28
  35. Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. A plan for voluntary mediation as alternative for malpractice claims doesn’t make it to the demonstration phase. September 2002. 2007;Available at: http://www.rwjf.org/reports/grr/033629.htm. Accessed January 28
  36. Liebman CB, Hyman CS. A mediation skills model to manage disclosure of errors and adverse events to patients. Health Aff. 2004;23:22–32
  37. McCullough, Campbell, and Lane LLP. Summary of Medical Malpractice Law. August 1998. 2006;Available at: http://www.mcandl.com/introduction.html. Accessed September 27
  38. Studdert DM, Fritz LA, Brennan TA. The jury is still in: Florida’s Birth-Related Neurological Injury Compensation Plan after a decade. J Health Politics Policy Law. 2000;25:499–526
  39. Metzloff TB. Researching litigation: the medical malpractice example. Law Contemp Probl. 1988;51:199–241
  40. Medical liability (Florida voters speak, but the court won’t listen (editorial)). In: American Medical News. 2006;p. 23;November 20
  41. Loser pays (editorial). The Wall Street Journal. 2006;A18;December 7
  42. Herman T. How to lower your tax-bill this year; More people get hit with stiff penalties for delaying tactics or frivolity. The Wall Street Journal. 2006;September 13
  43. John Edwards on Government Reform. OnTheIssues. November 7, 2003. 2006;Available at: http://ontheissues.org/2004/John_Edwards_Government_Reform.htm. Accessed September 14
  44. Hurt C. Edwards’ malpractice suits leave bitter taste. The Washington Times. August 16, 2004. 2006;Available at:http://www.washingtontimes.com. Accessed September 14
  45. Nelson KB. Can we prevent cerebral palsy. N Engl J Med. 2003;349:1765–1769
  46. Larson A. New Mexico statute of limitations for civil and personal injury actions: an overview. expertLaw. July 2004. 2006;Available at: http://www.expertlaw.com/library/limitations_by_state/New_Mexico.htlm. Accessed September 29
  47. Massey B. Medical malpractice suit rules change for kids. The Albuquerque Journal. August 19, 2004. 2006;Available at: http://www.abqjournal.com. Accessed September 29
  48. Landro L. Doctors learn to say “I’m sorry.”. The Wall Street Journal. 2007;D5;January 24
  49. Crossen C. “Cognitive dissonance” became a milestone in 1950’s psychology. The Wall Street Journal. 2006;B1;December 4
  50. Renshaw AA. Improving consensus on the cause of cytologic-histologic discrepancy. Am J Clin Pathol. 2006;126:831–832
  51. American Tort Reform Association. South Carolina Reforms. 2005. 2006;Available at: http://www.atra.org/states/SC. Accessed October 29
  52. Kridelbaugh WW, Palmisano DJ. A 20-year experience with malpractice screening panels. Highlights from the Bulletin, American College of Surgeons. Vol 82, May 1997. 2006;Available at: http://www.facs.org/ahp/proliab/malpanel.html. Accessed September 15
  53. Medical Malpractice Screening Panels. Abramson, Brown, & Dugan, Attorneys. LexisNexis, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. 2006. 2006;Available at: http://www.arbd.com. Accessed September 15
  54. Kasprak J. Maine-malpractice screening panel. OLR Research Report. November 28, 2003. 2006;Available at: http://cga.ct.gov/2003/olrdata/ph/rpt/2003-R-0871.htm. Accessed September 15
  55. Margolick D. Suit filed to abolish medical malpractice panels. The New York Times. February 27, 1983. 2006;Available at: http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?sec=health&res=9403EFD7133BF934A15751C0A965948260. Accessed September 15
  56. N.H advances med-mal screening panel. Insurance Journal. May 3, 2004. 2006;Available at: http://www.insurancejournal.com/news/east/2004/05/03/41769.htm. Accessed September 15
  57. Sorrel AL. States cautious about tort reform success. American Medical News. 2006;13;September 11
  58. Sorrel AL. Florida doctors and lawyers turn to waivers after tort ruling. American Medical News. 2006;10;November 6
  59. Peretz M. Beyond the Shores of Tripoli. Book review of: Power, Faith, and Fantasy, by Michael Oren. The Wall Street Journal. 2007;W6;January 12
  60. Why lawyers object to having a physician on a malpractice screening panel. Kevin, MD Medical Weblog. April 4, 2005. 2006;Available at: http://www.kevinmd.com/blog/2005/04/why-lawyers-object-having-physician-on.html. Accessed September 15
  61. Fried C. Mr. Stimson and the American way. The Wall Street Journal. 2007;A21;January 16
  62. Bernstein DE. Quackspertise. The Wall Street Journal Weekend Edition. 2006;A9;September 30
  63. Kassirer JP, Cecil JS. Inconsistency in evidentiary standards for medical testimony (Disorder in the courts). JAMA. 2002;288:1382–1387
  64. Petroski H. Daubert and Kumho. Am Scientist. 1999;87:402–406
  65. Foucar E. Pathology expert witness testimony and pathology practice (A tale of 2 standards). Arch Pathol Lab Med. 2005;129:1268–1276
  66. US Supreme Court, 509 U.S. 579 (1993). Daubert v Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc. 2003;Available at: http://supct.law.cornell.edu. Accessed December 22
  67. Cho A. Fingerprinting doesn’t hold up as science in court. Science. 2002;295:418
  68. Faigman DL. Is science different for lawyers. Science. 2002;297:339–340
  69. U.S. Supreme Court, 522 U.S. 136 (1997). General Electric Co v Joiner. 2003;Available at: http://supct.law.cornell.edu. Accessed on December 22
  70. Noah L, Weintraub MI. Standards for expert medical testimony. (letter) J Am Med Assoc. 2002;288:2971–2972
  71. Deftos L, Faigman DL. Many courts still Frye scientific evidence. (letter) Science. 2002;297:1275–1276
  72. Foucar E. There are ways to ensure valid science trials. (letter) The Wall Street Journal. 2006;A19;October 9
  73. Federal Rules of Evidence (2004). Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute. 2006;Available at: http://law.cornell.edu/rules/fre/. Accessed August 25
  74. Kesselheim AS, Studdert DM. Characteristics of physicians who frequently act as expert witnesses in neurologic birth injury litigation. Obstet Gynecol. 2006;108:273–279
  75. Beck M. The hired gun expert witness. Mol Med. 1994;91:179–182
  76. McCullough, Campbell, & Lane LLP. Summary of medical malpractice law, Pennsylvania. May 30, 2003. 2006;Available at: http://www.mcandl.com/pennsylvania.html#VI. Accessed October 30
  77. Finkel E. expert witness guidelines for the specialty of pathology. CAP TODAY. July 2006. 2006;Available at: http://www.cap.org/apps/cap.portal. Accessed October 30
  78. Sorrel AL. Fla. Supreme Court: experts can’t rely on others’ views. American Medical News. 2006;13;December 4
  79. Howard PK. Strong medicine. The Wall Street Journal. 2007;A6;January 6,7
  80. Sorrel AL. Senate weighs alternatives to medical liability system. American Medical News. 2006;5;July 17
  81. Liptak A. Doctor’s testimony leads to a complex legal fight. Mednews. June 23, 2004. 2006;Available at: http://www.josmc.org/pipermail/mednews/2004-June/000503.html. Accessed July 3
  82. Dr. John Fullerton v. The Florida Medical Association, Inc., Drs. Warach, Zala, and Krebs. Brief of Washington Legal Foundation as Amicus Curiae in support of defendant-appellee Florida Medical Association. June 20, 2005. 2006;Available at: http://wlf.org/Litigating/casedetail.asp?detail=304. Accessed September 6
  83. Sorrel AL. Courts split on medical societies’ role in policing expert witnesses. American Medical News. 2006;Vol 49:1;August 21
  84. In The United States Court for the District of Kansas. Case No. 05-1040-JTM. 29 June 2006. J. Clark Bundren, MD vs. Joel Parriott, MD. 2006;Available at: http://www.ksd.uscourts.gov/. Accessed September 7
  85. Riddick R. Doctors who testify as experts for med-mal plaintiffs can sue if peers discipline them. Law.com. July 14, 2006. 2006;Available at: http://www.law.com. Accessed August 24
  86. Sorrel AL. California high court shields peer reviewers. American Medical News. 2006;13;August 21
  87. Sorrel AL. Michigan high court lets physician sue over bad peer review. American Medical News. 2006;9;September 18
  88. Patrick v Burget, et al.486 U.S. 94 (1988), Supreme Court of the United States. 2006;Available at: http://biotech.law.lsu.edu/cases/antitrust/patrick.htm. Accessed October 8
  89. Adams D. State laws aim to buttress role of medical boards. American Medical News. 2006;Volume 49:16;August 28
  90. The AANS Professional Conduct Program. October 2006. 2006;Available at: http://www.aans.org/about/membership/professional_conduct10_06.pdf. Accessed October 30
  91. Pelton RM. Professing professional conduct: AANS raises the bar for expert testimony. Bulletin, AANS.ORG. Spring 2002. 2006;Available at: http://www.aans.org/library/article.aspx?ArticleId=9916. Accessed October 30
  92. Pelton RM. The AANS professional conduct program. The AAOS Bulletin. April 2005. 2006;Available at: http://www.aaos.org/News/Bulletin/apr05/fline4.asp. Accessed October 30
  93. Casey B. ACR suspends member for malpractice testimony. Radiology Insider Imaging Center. March 30, 2006. 2006;Available at: http://www.auntminnie.com. Accessed July 26
  94. Hawthorne effect. Wikipedia. Last modified October 4, 2006. 2006;Available at: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawthorne_effect. Accessed October 6
  95. Ackerman AB. A trial in Philadelphia and matters that transcend it. Dermatopathol Pract Concept. 2000;6:236–250
  96. New Mexico Medical Practice Act, Sections 61-6-1 through 61-6-35 NMSA 1978. 2006;Available at: http://www.nmmb.state.nm.us/. Accessed September 6
  97. Rice B. Putting your license at risk. Medical Economics. Nov 8, 2002. 2006;Available at: http://memag.com. Accessed December 28
  98. H-265.993 Peer Review of Medical expert Witness Testimony. 2006;Available at: http://www.truthinjustice.org/FSMB.htm. Accessed August 24
  99. FSMB issues guidance. Amednews.com. June 28, 2004. 2006;Available at: http://www.ama-assn.org. Accessed August 2
  100. Collins E. Medical witness backed by court. News-Record.com. Greensboro, North Carolina. June 7, 2006. 2006;Available at: http://www.news-record.com. Accessed June 30
  101. Riddick R. Florida doctor prevails in license fight over expert testimony. Law.com. June 28, 2006. 2006;Available at: http://www.law.com. Accessed August 24
  102. North Carolina Court of Appeals, No. COA05-891. IN RE. Gary James Lustgarten, MD. Filed 6 June 2006. 2006;Available at: http://www.aoc.state.nc.us/www/public/coa/opinions/2006/050891-1.htm. Accessed September 7
  103. Adams D. South Carolina Supreme Court halts out-of-state expert witness rule. Amednews.com. September 11, 2006. 2006;Available at: http://www.ama-assn.org/amanews/2006. Accessed September 15
  104. The Supreme Court of South Carolina. Re. Act No. 385 of 2006: relating to defining the “practice of medicine.”. 2007;Available at: http://www.scbar.org/pdf/CLE/TortLawUpdate.pdf. Accessed January 5
  105. Sorrel AL. Judges hit classroom to learn about medicine. American Medical News. 2006;Vol 49:1;April 17
  106. Lane E. Neuroscience in the courts: a revolution in justice (Science and Law). Science. 2006;313:458
  107. Sorrel AL. Georgia liability plaintiffs don’t have to wave privacy. American Medical News. 2006;14;August 14
  108. The People &C., Respondent v. Resean Hues, Appellant. New York Court of Appeals. November 20, 1998. 2006;Available at: http://www.law.cornell.edu/nyctap/I98_0140.htm. Accessed October 9
  109. Liptak A, Roberts J. Campaign cash mirrors a high court’s rulings. The New York Times. October 1, 2006. 2006;Available at: http://www.nytimes.com. Accessed October 1
  110. Samuels D. The New York Times. December 12, 2006. 2006;Available at: http://select.nytimes.com. Accessed December 19
  111. Judicial politics run amok (editorial). The New York Times. September 19, 2006. Available at: http://www.nytimes.com. Accessed September 19, 2006.
  112. Strassel KA. Corporate America takes on Spitzerism. The Wall Street Journal. 2006;A14;September 25
  113. John C. Nelson, MD, MPH, President, AMA. Letter written to members of the American Medical Association. November 1, 2004.
  114. McKinnon JD. Upping the dosage: fearing a democratic victory, drug makers fund key races. The Wall Street Journal. 2006;A1;October 25
  115. Inglehart JK. The malpractice morass:symbol of societal conflict. Health Aff. 2004;23:7–8
  116. Studdert DM, Mello MM, Gawande AA, et al. Claims, errors, and compensation payments in medical malpractice litigation. N Engl J Med. 2006;354:2024–2033
  117. Sage WM. The forgotten third: liability insurance and the medical malpractice crisis. Health Aff. 2004;23:10–21

PII: S0740-2570(07)00052-4

doi: 10.1053/j.semdp.2007.03.010

Seminars in Diagnostic Pathology
Volume 24, Issue 2 , Pages 131-147 , May 2007

Article Tools